Kenny's Castaways

My boyfriend and I got out to Montauk late in the evening and were starving. We haven't been out this way in awhile but decided to take a chance on Kenny's. I'm so happy we did! I first called...

Talk about awkward... upon arriving, you're greeted with a sign at the door that tells customers not to listen to what people at the inn are saying about them. The inn and restaurant are on the...

The food was generally good, and Mario who took care of us was nice. There is one thing that I must draw attention to. My party was charged for 5 baskets of garlic bread at $7 a plate for a total...

For the time of year, one of the few places open. Adjacent to our hotel. Across from the water but no water view- just boats in line of sight. Warm, homey feel- live music some nights, locals...

We must have driven past Kenny's a million times, and my cousins even stayed here at the hotel... but never ate at the restaurant. We just got off a two hour sunset catamaran and wanted somewhere...