Kay Jewelers

Closed
yelp logo

(2)

Call
Website
999 Montauk Hwy
Shirley, NY 11967
+1 (631) 399-2010
https://stores.kay.com
Since 1916, Kay Jewelers has grown from one store to more than 1,100 from coast to coast. As the #1 jewelry store in America, we know that offering fine jewelry at a great price is only part of the story...

Also at this address

Reviews

yelp logo
1.52 reviews
Evelyn M.
4/5/2025

I got a beautiful Diamond promise ring The sales lady was very nice to help me . My only issue is that I was not able to but on the extended warranty and I paid separately to size my ring . And...

Read more on Yelp
Jason G.
7/18/2025

They sent me home, after completely over charging me, which would have been fine, except they lied to me about having it custom sized. They forced the piece onto a chain too large and ruined both....

Read more on Yelp
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Kay Jewelers
Jewelry, precious stones and precious metals, Repair services, nec, nec, Time piece repair services

Kay Jewelers

74
•
$$
"EXCELLENT AND GREAT BUSINESS. Very professional and understanding of exactly what you need. They helped me big time for my engagement ring for my girlfriend. AMAZING SERVICE TO EVERYBODY IN THE..."
Jewelry, precious stones and precious metals, Repair services, nec, nec

Kay Jewelers

7
•
$
"I really like them. I walked in with having bad credit and I got approved for 1000$ store credit with no interest for 1 year. I spent the whole 1000$ credit almost 6 months ago and have paid my..."
Michaels Jewelers
Jewelry, precious stones and precious metals, Time piece repair services, Repair services, nec, nec

Michaels Jewelers

5
•
$$$
"They re really great there! Got my engagement ring from there!!! Just simply beautiful!!! It still sparkles like the first day!!!! Great prices!!!!!!! awesome prices!!!!! Great very kind..."
United States›New York›Shirley›Kay Jewelers

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.