Jimmy Hays Steak House

$$$$
Open
yelp logo

(367)

Photos

4310 Austin Blvd
Island Park, NY 11558

Jimmy Hays Steak House is a legendary establishment in Island Park, NY, known for its rich history and exceptional dining experience. Founded by the remarkable Jimmy McCluskey over three quarters of a century ago, the restaurant continues to uphold the McCluskey Tradition under the guidance of Jimmy's grandson, Jimmy Hays. With a focus on serving the finest steaks, chops, and lobsters, Jimmy Hays Steak House offers a warm and welcoming atmosphere where guests can enjoy delicious food and be greeted by Jimmy Hays himself, dressed in the same attire as his beloved grandfather.

Carrying on the legacy of his legendary grandfather, Jimmy Hays ensures that every visit to Jimmy Hays Steak House is a memorable one. From the moment guests step through the doors, they are transported back in time to an era of New York history, where the likes of Al Smith, Jimmy Walker, Jack Dempsey, and Abie's Irish Rose roamed the city. With a commitment to providing impeccable service and delectable cuisine, Jimmy Hays Steak House is a true gem in the heart of Island Park, offering a taste of the past with a touch of modern elegance.

Generated from the website

Reviews

yelp logo
3.5367 reviews
Madison M.
9/2/2025

Tuesdays with pat 100/10 recommend. G bread. Suga rim lemon drop martinis. Emphasis on the period.

Photo of Michelle Z.
Michelle Z.
7/19/2025

Went on a Friday night with my 22 year old son who is in a wheelchair. Informed them about this when made the reservation. Place was very accommodating, friendly and made our experience there...

Photo of Leticia C.
Leticia C.
6/7/2025

All the dishes were spectacular, especially a special appetizer that had scallops/octopus & asparagus (truly delicious). All staff was accommodating of our 11 month old guest, they were...

Photo of Chuck G.
Chuck G.
6/30/2025

This has now become my standard for judging steakhouses on Long Island. From the waitstaff to the appetizers, main course and dessert, as close to perfect as I have had on the Island. Steak and...

Photo of David R.
David R.
6/3/2025

Celebrated my 51st birthday with a bone in filet and topped with lobster. Wife had beef Wellington. Drinks was a Manhattan and a dirty martini with blue cheese stuffed olives. Appetizers was...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesNew YorkIsland ParkJimmy Hays Steak House

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.