William K.
9/9/2025
Whoever said Shelter Island goes to sleep after Labor Day clearly hasn't been to Isola. This gem of a restaurant is alive with energy, laughter, and the kind of warm Italian hospitality that keeps...
Isola
$$$$
Closed
(82)
Photos
15 Grand Ave
Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
Isola in Shelter Island Heights, Shelter Island, NY, is a charming Italian restaurant that offers a true taste of Shelter Island living. With a mix of classic Italian dishes prepared with modern twists, an inviting wine list, and a curated cocktail menu, Isola provides a delightful dining experience in a relaxed and inspiring atmosphere.
Owned by Brad Kitkowski, a lover of Italian food and Shelter Island, Isola features indoor and outdoor seating, a traditional bar, and a wood-fired, brick oven pizza kitchen. Guests can enjoy their meals in the lively main dining room, spacious bar, side patio, or on the scenic front porch overlooking the Historic Shelter Island Heights District.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.582 reviewsRosie R.
8/16/2025
Ordered a margarita pizza - and the crispy eggplant parm dish. The pizza was a bit doughy and the 'crispy' eggplant parm dish was anything but crispy. It was disappointing. Did not replicate the...
Carol D.
8/26/2025
Great food! Actually, it tasted like real Italian food. Great service. The owner even came over to make sure everything was well. Prices were actually reasonable and the wine selection good. It...
Anthony L.
2/9/2025
Food was great and fairly priced. Also loved the drinks , especially "blood and sand" Was a fun crowd especially for karaoke and the owner hangs out and sings as well Bartender Eric did a great...
Geri M.
5/14/2025
Food is great and the owner is very engaging ! Music most nights and karaoke on Fridays, which is great fun!
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.