Island Paradise

Permanently closed
yelp logo

(6)

Photos

1702 Middle Country Rd
Centereach, NY 11720

Reviews

yelp logo
1.06 reviews
Valerie T.
1/31/2016

My husband, my niece and I just had dinner there. Place was sparse, yet drinks took a while. Appetizer served late, main course followed within 5 minutes. Rib eye was fatty, burger overcooked,...

Photo of Mike J.
Mike J.
10/23/2015

This place was "under construction" for what felt like years. It finally opened last month and I had the chance to try it out. The front of the building has a very uninviting look. Likely from...

Photo of Mike S.
Mike S.
12/19/2015

In the short of it do not eat there the food sucks. The drinks were overpriced. The baked potatoes tasted like they were made the day before. The pork was tough and beef was like shoe leather. On...

Photo of Jon S.
Jon S.
12/12/2015

I worked there for 3 weeks and the things I saw were unethical and unsanitary.. The beer was old and stale the meats were gray and spoiled the seafood slimy and smelly yet they still served the...

Photo of Kerri K.
Kerri K.
12/28/2015

I'm so glad to finally see this on Yelp. we went the first week it was open and we were so excited. Well, we were one of 3 tables in there and it took almost 2 hours for dinner for 2. we...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesNew YorkCentereachIsland Paradise

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.