Island Mermaid

$$$
Closed
yelp logo

(364)

Call
Website

Photos

780 Bay Walk
Ocean Beach, NY 11770
+1 (631) 583-8088
http://www.islandmermaid.com
Island Mermaid is a restaurant, bar and dance club that offers a variety of dining and catering options. The restaurant specializes in American-style cuisine. It serves a selection of soups, salads, entrees, starters, appetizers and burgers. Island Mermaid serves rigatoni campagna, saute d grouper fillet, sesame-coated halibut, beef filet mignon and Thai teriyaki salmon. The restaurant s lunch specialties include Thai tuna tataki, Tasmanian crab salad, lobster rolls and mermaid crab cakes. It also offers grilled portabella and Tuscan chicken panini, as well as tuna salad and turkey club wraps. Island Mermaid s wine menu includes chardonnay, cabernet sauvignon, pinot noir, merlot, pinot grigio and sauvignon blanc. The restaurant provides catering services for various events, such as weddings, engagements, graduations, birthday parties, anniversaries and corporate outings.

Also at this address

Reviews

yelp logo
3.5364 reviews
Photo of Lou D.
Lou D.
9/7/2025

Had a giant lobster roll at sundown! Wow! Good! Ocean Beach Fire Island, Steps away from the Ocean Beach Ferry. Really easy to get to! Super super service! Huge shout out to our pro server Cat...

Read more on Yelp
Dr. Craig R.
9/11/2025

Had another great meal at the Mermaid. Had some of the best fried calamari you can get anywhere and my wife and I order it most places that have it on the menu. Perfectly cooked which isn't easy...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Precious J.
Precious J.
7/17/2025

What an Amazing place. Great view. Great service. Reasonably priced. Staff was friendly and went out their way for my daughter's birthday. Our Hostess Catherine was absolutely charming..

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Hiromi Y.
Hiromi Y.
9/5/2024

Every summer, one of our regulation is coming to Fire island and end up this restaurant. Mostly being here for labor day weekend. But we came here Labor day Monday.. so Lille bit slower than...

Read more on Yelp
Brenda T.
8/25/2025

It's overpriced and food was not good! I got the simple fish $40, it was supposed to be broiled flounder, I think it was talapia! It was salty, wasn't broiled! It came wide sticky white rice and...

Read more on Yelp
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Albatross
Eating places, Bars and lounges, Bar (drinking places)

Albatross

92
•
$$
"Great food, fun bar, wonderfully helpful and friendly staff. Good vegetarian options and they're awesome with allergies too. Easily my favorite spot for lunch or dinner in Ocean Beach. Tip: start..."
Italian restaurant, Bars and lounges

Surf's Out

Surf's Out, founded by Paul and Barbara, has been a staple of Kismet for over a decade, celebrated for its vibrant cocktails and exceptional food on Fire Island. As of Summer 2021, the beloved establishment has transitioned to new ownership, marking a bittersweet moment for its founders who plan to return to Long Island in the future. During its tenure, Surf's Out hosted countless memorable events, including weddings, birthdays, and lively gatherings beneath the full moon. The founders express deep gratitude to their loyal customers, dedicated staff, and supportive families, all of whom have enriched their summer experiences. Generated from the website
Fratelli Pizzeria
Eating places, Italian restaurant, Bar (drinking places)

Fratelli Pizzeria

69
•
$
"This restaurant never fails to make me happy! The food is consistently delicious and the owners put their heart and soul into ensuring that their customers are always satisfied. If a customer..."
photo of Kate B.
United States›New York›Ocean Beach›Island Mermaid

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.