Dr C.
7/4/2025
Always delicious, wide variety of flavors. Staff behind the counter very accommodating Will be back soon
Ice Cream Social
$$
Closed
(105)
Photos
1153 Jericho Tpke
Commack, NY 11725
Ice Cream Social, located in Commack, NY, is a family-owned establishment that offers artisanal ice cream handcrafted by James Beard Chef Rob McCue. Co-owned by his wife Christine, a Master Cake Designer and Art Teacher, the shop features an impressive selection of 64 flavors along with vegan options and health-conscious choices like Only 8 frozen yogurt and fat-free soft serve.
In addition to their unique ice cream offerings, Ice Cream Social provides custom-designed specialty cakes for any occasion, as well as a variety of hand-blended shakes, egg creams, floats, malteds, and sodas. They also stock traditional and no sugar added chocolate confections available by the pound or platter, emphasizing quality and creativity in every product.
Generated from the website
Reviews
4.0105 reviews
Jaimie Y.
8/30/2025
This place's coffee mud slide flavor is one of the best ice cream flavors I've ever had in my life I'm pretty sure
Adina S.
9/21/2024
A solid ice cream spot, lots of flavors. The ice cream had just the right consistency, creamy and not too icy. Pretty standard in terms of service and atmosphere. I will say the ice cream did seem...
Mindy M.
2/1/2025
James is a fine server at Icecream Social in Commack NY. He knows all the flavors and says that the ice cream is made there fresh. There is the soft serve as well. Lots of types and toppings....
Kristy F.
9/25/2024
5 years ago I wrote a review for this place when it was Granny's and gave it 5 stars, raving about amazing it was. I moved away and just came back and went to stop in and get my favorite only 8...
See a problem?
