Alexarose M.
8/3/2025
great quick service and delicious ice cream! very accommodating of gluten allergies as well
Ice Cream Cottage
$
Closed
(226)
Photos
1590 Montauk Hwy
Mastic, NY 11950
The Ice Cream Cottage is a beloved ice cream shop located in Mastic, NY, offering a wide variety of super premium ice cream flavors that have won multiple awards, including the coveted Best Ice-Cream Cone on Long Island. With a charming interior that reflects both nostalgia and modern sensibilities, the Ice Cream Cottage has become a popular destination for locals and visitors alike.
Known for their friendly staff and exceptional ice cream, the Ice Cream Cottage offers an extensive menu of flavors, including classics like chocolate and vanilla, as well as unique options like Chocolate Overdose and Peanut Butter Jelly. In addition to their delicious ice cream, the Ice Cream Cottage also offers custom cakes and seasonal flavors, ensuring there's something for everyone to enjoy.
Generated from the website
Reviews
4.5226 reviews
Evan C.
7/26/2025
It was one of those days only ice cream could make better. You know, those long days with no end in sight. "Ice Cream Cottage" was in my bookmarks for a long time. Today I was in the area and...
I B.
8/29/2025
Visited this establishment today, and ordered a pralines and cream in a cup, and my significant other had a strawberry cheesecake cone. The ice cream was delicious (better than Mr. Softee) and the...
Jerry K.
11/3/2024
If you are reading this review instead of getting on the line to order you're already wasted too much time. I didn't know what to expect when the suggestion came up to come here, or if I thought...
Jessica H.
10/23/2024
Don't be fooled by the outdated and small look - this is the most delicious ice cream you'll have on Long Island! Living close to this place is very dangerous, as we already went back twice in 1...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.