Diana Q.
9/27/2025
Eclectic merchandise...store is a bit overcrowded but the staff is lovely and they have a large selection of real gold jewelry!!!
Hidden Treasures Thrift Shop
Open
(10)
Photos
1601 5th Ave
Bay Shore, NY 11706
Hidden Treasures Thrift Shop in Bay Shore, NY is a small yet diverse thrift store that offers a wide range of items at affordable prices, making it a favorite among bargain hunters. With weekly discounts and a constantly changing inventory, customers can always expect to find something new and exciting.
From clothing to household items, Hidden Treasures Thrift Shop provides a variety of selections, ensuring that there is something for everyone. Whether you visit on a weekday or weekend, you are bound to discover great finds that will make your shopping experience worthwhile.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.010 reviews
Rohini G.
6/14/2025
I loved the selection of items here. Yes, parking is tight, and the store is quite cramped, but it's organized by item and size relatively well. All sale prices were half the value on the tag. Got...
Rob H.
5/17/2025
Store personnel here are helpful and friendly. They won't hesitate to stop whatever they're doing to answer a question or help you find something. Parking spots in front of the store are few- I...
Melanie H.
5/16/2025
The parking lot of the place is pretty small. The staff is very nice and helpful. Overpriced but did have a good amount of name brand items and selection. Things are not organized in a lot of the...
Jessica R.
7/24/2021
I found this thrift shop while googling other ones to go to. I went there, and the parking lot is super small. I wanna say maybe 5 cars can fit in front of the shop, and maybe one car on the side....
See a problem?
