Linda M.
9/3/2025
I do have a soft spot for ice cream, more specifically frozen custard. So when I saw that Hibbard's had frozen custard we just had to stop. I ordered a chocolate (I know, boring to some) but...
Hibbard's Custard
$
Open
(112)
Photos
105 Portage Rd
Lewiston, NY 14092
Hibbard's Custard, a family-owned and operated business since 1939, has been delighting the Village of Lewiston and its surrounding areas with their original frozen custard. Made fresh throughout the day, their custard is known for its rich and creamy texture, thanks to the design of their custard machine that pumps in less air compared to ice cream. With a wide variety of flavors and selections, Hibbard's Custard offers a delicious treat that will leave your taste buds satisfied.
Using their secret recipe and a commitment to quality, Hibbard's Custard has earned a reputation for serving some of the best frozen custard in New York. Customers rave about the wide range of flavors available and the affordable prices. Whether you're a fan of classic favorites or looking to try something new, Hibbard's Custard is sure to impress with their top-notch and delicious frozen custard.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.5112 reviews
Monica K.
7/21/2025
Quick, friendly service. They only have take away or outdoor seating available on a deck with a decent amount of space between seats. They offer 7 options daily of their house made custard 4 core...
Bonnie T.
6/14/2025
Returned to Hibbard's for a birthday treat for myself. I had a taste of the Lavberry- lavender & blueberry, but the taste was too complicated for me. I got a vanilla, it was very tasty. I think...
Mark A.
8/9/2025
Doesn't get better than Hibbard's! Homemade custard hits the spot every time. They serve Perry's along with a variety (usually 4 to 8 various flavors) of homemade custard. Small parking lot but...
John K.
6/20/2025
The homemade custards here are amazing. The pistachio custard is especially good and addictive. Hoping they will have the banana custard on the menu again next time I go back.
See a problem?
