Gustaly

Permanently closed
yelp logo

(25)

Call

Photos

796 9th Ave # 52
New York, NY 10019

Reviews

yelp logo
4.025 reviews
Photo of Dean C.
Dean C.
11/8/2019

This place is delicious!!! Came here for lunch with my friend and I enjoyed the vegetable ministeone, spaghetti and meatballs and the salad. the pasta here is super fresh and authentic - a little...

Photo of Scott P.
Scott P.
7/26/2019

First USA branch (2019) of the acclaimed eatery in Bologna, Italy (1964) offering super authentic Italian fare including homemade pastas & desserts. The experience is so Italian that you're sure...

Photo of Lee S.
Lee S.
12/16/2019

Technically my rating is 4.5. 4 for the experience, and an extra .5 because they're still new and want them to do well. The best dishes were the caprese salad and the pasta with sausage and...

Photo of Nick C.
Nick C.
8/11/2019

It was the middle of the summer when I had lunch at Gustaly. I was the only patron who was seated but they were doing an aggressive takeout business on the day I was there. It is a very small...

Photo of Laura C.
Laura C.
10/23/2019

My brother and I came here the other night before seeing a show. Their short yet enticing menu made it easy to decide quickly, my brother had the pesto and I had bolognese. I tried some of his...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like