Salvatore G.
9/8/2025
Great place, great people. Family owned and a fantastic place for collectors. I enjoy stopping by during events and otherwise.
Gotham City Games
Permanently closed
(35)
Photos
503 84th St
Brooklyn, NY 11209
History
Gotham Games started four years ago out of a love for gaming. Online sales eventually grew to the Brooklyn Flea and other flea markets. Until the collection was large enough to move into a brick and mortar store in Bay Ridge Brooklyn.
Specialties
Brooklyn's only retro game shop, we specialize in classic and vintage gaming from 1980s and 1990s. As well as stocking up on classic games, we also stock used new generations games. We also have new games for all for systems at the cheapest price guranteed. Weekly tournaments with store credit prizes
Also at this address
Reviews
4.535 reviews
Ken P.
3/6/2019
Truth be told if you were not looking for this place you would risk missing it as its not on the main thoroughfare of the Bay Ridge avenue and instead just a few stores up the block. Its a small...
Cat D.
9/24/2015
I came back and took more pictures. He had a lot more than the last time I came. This time, the place was busier. It took me way back...to the point where I felt old. There were youngins in there....
Cody C.
12/6/2019
Small but well-curated shop with fair prices and a regularly updated selection. I'd much rather buy old video games at this store than any of the couple others in the city that charge way more and...
Jonathan T.
6/12/2017
the store is fairly small with a decent selection of preowned older games. They have lots of rare titles as well as common cartridges as well. Staff is knowledgable and they really love their...
See a problem?