Jennifer L.
8/25/2025
If you love a good chunky and gooey cookie then this is the place for you. They have many fun unique flavors and the staff members were very chill and nice. They have a happy hour where the...
Gooey on the Inside
$$
Closed
(330)
Photos
163 Chrystie St Bsmt
New York, NY 10002
Gooey on the Inside is a renowned bakery in New York City, specializing in crafting the most delectable ooey gooey cookies that are sure to satisfy any sweet tooth.
With a commitment to quality and flavor, Gooey on the Inside offers a mouthwatering cookie menu that will leave you craving for more, making it a must-visit destination for cookie enthusiasts in the city.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.0330 reviews
Andrew D.
9/6/2025
Three stars. Period. While I commemorate the owner for gaining traction amidst the blooming NYC cookie scene , I can't say Gooey on The Inside stands out from the lot. That noted, I give them...
Christine Y.
7/28/2025
Pricing is pretty high in 2025 for a cookie. Below is the pricing over the years. $5 - 2020-2022 $6 - 2023 $7 - 2024 $8 - 2025 It is nice and thick but a bit too decadent for 1 person. I also...
Jeff M.
4/8/2025
Gooey On The Inside 163 Chrystie St. New York, NY 10002 Nutella Cookie The contents of the nutella cookie was too sugary and overbearing in taste. The cookie was undercooked, which resulted in...
Phallon P.
8/30/2025
I ordered the Dubai chocolate cookie and the chai snickerdoodle. They were both warm when they arrived by the delivery driver and packaged nicely. These are two flavors my family loves but none of...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.