Maria R.
11/9/2025
Great pizza great service !!! You can eat there but I prefer to eat it at home.Try it you'll love it
Goodfellas Restaurant & Pizzeria
$$
Closed
(47)
Photos
47 Vassar Rd
Poughkeepsie, NY 12603
Goodfellas Restaurant & Pizzeria offers a menu focused on pizza, with a variety of choices available for customers. The pizza is prepared in-house and is designed to be cooked for serving. The restaurant aims to provide a casual dining experience.
While there are mixed opinions about the overall atmosphere and service, the portions served are noted to be generous. The establishment presents itself as a local option for those looking to enjoy pizza in a straightforward setting. Goodfellas strives to cater to a diverse range of pizza preferences.
Generated from the web
Reviews
3.547 reviews
Ernie F.
2/5/2025
Ordered takeout on my first visit. When I called over the phone, simply say your order. They do not ask for your name, which could make life difficult if your memory isn't great. I settled with...
Carolyn F.
3/26/2023
I haven't been in here in quite a while, in part, because the guys behind the counter tend to be rude. somethings never change. They didn't say anything offensive to me, but they just come off a...
John S.
6/13/2023
Classic, authentic NY pizza! Slices, whole pies, wedges...great casual place for lunch or dinner. Lots of space for dining in. The service is great and these guys have a good sense of humor....
Samm N.
8/30/2024
The waitress who served us was so incredibly kind. However, the food is just bad. Pasta was mushy and overcooked, veal was dry and bland, the sauce gave me instant heartburn. Pizza was ok, not...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.