Lily H.
12/8/2024
While visiting Niagara Falls, I was craving an authentic New York-style pizza experience. Yelp led me to Goodfellas Pizzeria, and it did not disappoint. The pizza lived up to the hype. The crust...
Goodfellas Pizzeria
$
Closed
(91)
Photos
745 W Market St
Niagara Falls, NY 14301
Goodfellas Pizzeria, established in 1992, is a cherished eatery located in Niagara Falls, NY, renowned for its hand-spun New York style pizza and a variety of appetizers. Nestled in City Market Plaza, this throw-back style pizzeria prides itself on using fresh, house-made dough, solid red sauce, and freshly grated mozzarella, all resulting in a truly authentic pizza experience.
With a menu offering everything from classic pizzas to subs and wings, Goodfellas has become a favorite among locals and visitors alike. The restaurant provides a welcoming atmosphere for dine-in, take-out, and delivery, ensuring guests can indulge in their delicious offerings seamlessly.
Generated from the website
Reviews
3.591 reviews
Joseph S.
10/11/2024
My favorite pizza in New York so far. That taste was amazing!!! I did order double pepperoni and wow, very delicious. It had that great crunch to the bottom and the sauce was scrumptious....
Jillian D.
8/14/2025
$8 before tax. I had to remove the tinfoil because it was stuck to the cheese and had to drive back for more gravy.
Maya H.
7/22/2024
I'm a huge fan of the charbroiled wings, normal wings are also solid and they follow instructions if you like them cooked a certain way. we always get extra crispy and extra saucy, pizza is solid...
lisa j.
11/10/2023
From the exterior, sketchy building in back of a parking lot that contains McDonald's, Goodfellas does not look good. The exterior, and honestly the dining room doesn't look that much better hides...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.