Alison Z.
1/31/2022
We recently moved to the other side of Amsterdam and we couldn't be happier at our new options for pizza! First- I appreciate that they deliver. Our only option in our pervious home was always a...
Goodfellas Pizzeria
$$
Closed
(18)
Photos
1 Hewitt St
Amsterdam, NY 12010
Goodfellas Pizzeria, located in Amsterdam, New York, has been serving up delicious pizzas and traditional Italian dishes since its opening in 2006. With a commitment to New York-style pizza, every pizza and calzone is made to order and hand-tossed, ensuring freshness and quality with every bite.
As a local favorite, Goodfellas Pizzeria takes pride in its ability to adapt to the ever-changing pizza industry while maintaining its authentic flavors. Whether you choose to pick up your order or have it delivered to your door, you can be confident that each pizza is made with care and attention to detail. Come and experience the true taste of New York at Goodfellas Pizzeria.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.518 reviews
Dana J.
12/26/2024
Delivery is always a little slow but the food is good. We got a good portion size for the dinner and the pizzas (although cold by the time we got them) were tasty.
Kathleen B.
5/31/2024
Go to their web site and prices say one thing. Go to pick up the food and the price is double. It's not like I could not afford it but that's just false advertising. If I order again I'll ask...
thaddeus j.
2/7/2022
It's a nice little spot in Amsterdam, the pizza isn't anything special it had decent crisp and the pizza was just a little bland in general also where they keep the slices is not the most sanitary...
Jose A.
9/22/2023
waited for a pizza delivery for 1:40 minutes When I call the girl told me 10 min 30 min later I called the shop and he said 20 min more. Will never order from them again
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.