Sara R.
9/5/2018
This is my first time ordering from Gateway... I usually don't review a place until I've been there a few times to consider their consistency... but I am so impressed that I feel compelled to...
Gateway Bagels & Deli
$
Open
(45)
Photos
1875 Wantagh Ave
Wantagh, NY 11793
Gateway Bagels & Deli, located in Wantagh, NY, is a local favorite known for its delicious bagels and deli sandwiches. With a convenient location on Wantagh Avenue, customers can enjoy a variety of popular items made fresh daily.
Whether you're craving a classic bagel with cream cheese or a hearty deli sandwich, Gateway Bagels & Deli has something for everyone. Stop by to experience their tasty offerings and friendly service in the heart of Wantagh.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.045 reviewsDylan M.
8/15/2025
Not worth the price. Paid $11+ for a blt and it was as cheaply made as could be. Two slices of tomato, two slices of bacon- even the lettuce was light. Wouldn't return as there is much better...
Noah K.
3/9/2025
Decent bagel. Good chew with a crisp crust. Respectable schmear of cream cheese. $5 and change $6 w/ the tip. Not cheap. PS... anyone who orders a cinnamon bagel, scooped with bacon and American...
Patrick C.
5/31/2024
Hello Wantagh community, I rarely leave negative reviews for any business, but today I had such a disappointing experience at Gateway Bagel that I felt it was important to share. I ordered a...
Barry H.
8/22/2023
Sorry to keep whining about the same thing but geez, these people take a regular bagel, smoosh it down before baking it flat, spread a little cream cheese on it, and for that they charge you five...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.