Nelson T.
6/3/2025
Very simple! The Best Pizza.. Awesome meatballs sandwich or even just the meatballs without the bread. Everything is fresh. I can recommend this place all the time. Service is great too. Nice...
Gappy's Pizza
$$
Closed
(119)
Photos
1323 Route 52
Carmel, NY 10512
Gappy's Pizza in Carmel, NY, offers authentic New York-style pizza and Italian cuisine, renowned for its oversized pizza slices and award-winning sauce. Established in January 2002 by owner George Papazian, the restaurant has become a favorite among locals and travelers, providing a welcoming atmosphere where guests are treated like family.
With a diverse menu featuring everything from Margherita Pizza to freshly-made Mozzarella Sticks and Chicken Wings, Gappy's caters to a variety of tastes. The family-owned establishment prioritizes quality food, friendly service, and a clean environment, ensuring that each dining experience is satisfying and memorable.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.5119 reviews
Mr Bemis K.
8/17/2025
Are you kidding? Pizza? Shame, shame, shame. Maybe pizza soup! Forget the paper plates they should offer you straws with this slop. I can't believe this actually came out of their oven. What...
Karen M.
8/14/2025
Haven't been here in a while. Food was mediocre last night but listening to the loud mouth bartender drop the f bomb over and over was intolerable. Not going back again. This isn't family...
Oscar V.
7/28/2024
Was in the area and gave this place a try ordered a pizza half Hawaiian half meat lovers, this pizza was so good the flavor on the sauce was great as well as the toppings, have to say pizza...
Brian B.
10/2/2024
The business had been her for a LONG time so they are doing something right! All the food is amazing, the staff is wonderful. I wish they had online ordering but they are so busy it probably...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.