David E.
10/24/2025
This place is a boon to New Paltz. I had a great experience tonight. Craved chowder and calamari. The soup was good but the calamari exceeded expectations. Chowder was 3 out of five stars. It...
Gadaleto's Seafood
$$
Open
(98)
Photos
246 Main St
New Paltz, NY 12561
Gadaleto's Seafood, located in New Paltz, NY, offers a delightful combination of fresh fish and home-cooked food. Situated in the Cherry Hill Plaza, this establishment prides itself on providing quality seafood to the local community.
In addition to their fresh fish market, Gadaleto's Seafood features an eatery that showcases their culinary creations. Customers can enjoy a welcoming atmosphere as they indulge in a variety of seafood dishes prepared with care.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.598 reviews
Anne M.
10/2/2025
I'm from the south and I knew I NEEDED a lobster roll. 40 minute drive and so worth it. I recommend this place to anyone in the area. Shrimp p'boy and flounder sandwich was amazing!!!! Oysters...
Jadyn B.
8/21/2025
Lobster roll was loaded! 10/10 on flavor. Nice toasted buttery roll! Everything you love and need for a good classic lobster roll!
Darren G.
4/5/2024
I do really like fresh market side of this business, since the prices were fair and had great variety of fresh seafood even better then Adam's in respects. Like soft shell blue crab which is hard...
RoyGBiv S.
9/6/2024
I was craving fish 'n chips, and I have a route to bypass the traffic madness in New Paltz around lunchtime, so I thought, how about Gadaleto's? I have had fish 'n chips at a lot of places in...
See a problem?
