Gaby's Pizza

$
Closed
yelp logo

(578)

Photos

20423 Hillside Ave
Hollis, NY 11423
Gaby’s Pizza, located in the Fran Hill Mall on Hillside Avenue and Francis Lewis Boulevard, is consistently ranked year after year among the Top 10 Pizzerias in New York. Gaby’s Pizza represented New York City on the Rachael Ray show to compete against Chicago for the best pizza and won! Gaby’s Pizza is family owned and still uses the original recipes that were brought over in 1964 from Italy. The cheese is aged in the shop’s refrigerators and the dough is stretched out in olive oil and is topped with a sauce made from imported tomatoes from Italy before being baked upon a specially made screen.

Also at this address

Reviews

yelp logo
3.5578 reviews
Photo of Napoleon M.
Napoleon M.
7/17/2025

In my opinion, this service is good. The pizza is near perfect if not that. I've had catered lasagna from Gabby's. It was pretty good. The ambiance is casual and the aesthetics are that of an art...

Photo of Tamika V.
Tamika V.
11/7/2025

Gaby's has fallen off the good pizza list. They use to be so great, but the last two times I ordered was awful. It looked good, but looks are deceiving. On 11/6/25 I ordered half extra cheese and...

Photo of Wanda P.
Wanda P.
10/18/2025

"Great pizza!" Classic New York slice done right, crispy crust, gooey cheese, and just the right amount of sauce. Casual place with quick service, fair prices, and the kind of pizza that keeps you...

Photo of Tanya A.
Tanya A.
9/27/2025

The only pizzeria where I actually finish the crust. This place is so nostalgic, a Queens staple. Growing up this is where the teachers would order the pizza party pizza from. The space sits...

Erika J.
11/4/2025

Takeout perfection super cheesy pepperoni pizza. Sooooo hot and fresh!!! Loved it all the way down to the crust. Caesar salad was sub-par.

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesNew YorkHollisGaby's Pizza

Partial Data by Foursquare.