Frosty's Ice Cream

$
Closed
yelp logo

(114)

Call
Website

Photos

2424 George Urban Blvd
Depew, NY 14043
+1 (716) 697-1812
http://www.frostysicecream.com

Frosty's Ice Cream is a family-owned and operated ice cream shop that has been serving delicious ice cream with a smile for over 16 years. With two locations in Depew and Lancaster, New York, Frosty's offers a wide variety of over 40 flavors of hard ice cream, as well as specialty items like ice cream cakes and warm brownie sundaes. Whether you're looking for a classic vanilla cone or a unique frozen treat, Frosty's is the place to go for a delightful ice cream experience.

Known for their friendly atmosphere and generous portion sizes, Frosty's is a favorite spot for families and friends to come together and enjoy a sweet treat. With their commitment to quality and personal touch, Frosty's has become a beloved local ice cream destination. So, lift your spirits and indulge in the happiness that comes from a scoop of Frosty's ice cream.

Generated from the website

Reviews

yelp logo
4.5114 reviews
Photo of Frans D.
Frans D.
10/8/2025

Last time we visited we talked with the owner about some special flavors ice cream he has occasionally. Some might say weird, like pickle ice cream. It's almost the end of ice cream season so we...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Dave D.
Dave D.
7/25/2025

Nick you got yourself FIVE STARS!! First what an incredible welcome!! My out of town friend had never sampled loganberry so on the recommendation of friends we stopped by Frosty's on a VERY HOT...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Dab L.
Dab L.
7/23/2025

You get a lot of bang for your buck at this place! They serve Perry's ice cream and it's cash only... there are lots of options here for all the different ways to eat- vegan, dairy free, egg...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Margery Z.
Margery Z.
10/7/2025

The ice cream flavors are limited as Frosty's is closing for the season on October 17th. No chocolate so I had a one scoop "baby" cone of Mint-ting-a-ling. Nice and refreshing, even on a rainy day.

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Sabra R.
Sabra R.
9/12/2025

Winding down and closing for winter in October! Few more weeks till the long wait for next spring! SpongeBob candy sundae made my week oh so much better!

Read more on Yelp
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

PJ COOLS
Eating places, Fast food restaurants and stands

PJ COOLS

60
•
$
"Wow it too long to try this place. Very customer oriented and family friendly. We just wanted ice cream but it was cold outside. Decided to come here. They have lots of choices and options..."
photo of Connie P.
Anderson's Frozen Custard
Eating places, Fast food restaurants and stands

Anderson's Frozen Custard

45
•
$
"Today was my first time enjoying Anderson's Roast Beef & Frozen Custard. Probably the best roast beef on weck that I've had to date (better than Bar Bill, if you ask me). The roast beef was fresh,..."
photo of Lee R.
Anderson's Frozen Custard
Eating places, Fast food restaurants and stands

Anderson's Frozen Custard

115
•
$
"I had Anderson's the other day in Cheektowaga, but this Anderson's is much nicer (not so ratchet). Tried the turkey sandwich instead of roast beef this time, and it was no disappointment. Once..."
photo of Lee R.
United States›New York›Depew›Frosty's Ice Cream

Partial Data by Foursquare.