Kelly T.
7/26/2025
This is not a pink cup -- it's a loganberry milkshake! Even as a Buffalonian, I was skeptical of this tasting good. I was pleasantly surprised by the flavor and want another one already! Also,...
Frosty's Ice Cream
$
Closed
(59)
Photos
5500 Broadway St
Lancaster, NY 14086
Frosty's Ice Cream is a family-owned and operated ice cream shop that has been serving delicious ice cream with a smile for over 16 years. With two locations in Lancaster and Depew, New York, Frosty's offers a wide variety of over 40 flavors of hard ice cream, as well as specialty items like ice cream cakes and warm brownie sundaes. Whether you're looking for a classic vanilla cone or a unique frozen treat, Frosty's is the place to go for a tasty and refreshing ice cream experience.
Known for their friendly atmosphere and generous portion sizes, Frosty's is a favorite spot for families and friends to come together and enjoy a sweet treat. With a commitment to quality and a personal touch, Frosty's uses real custard and high-quality ingredients to create their delicious ice cream creations. Whether you're in the mood for a traditional cone or a custom-decorated ice cream cake, Frosty's is dedicated to putting a smile on your face and lifting your spirits with their delectable ice cream delights.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.559 reviews
Donna W.
8/4/2025
Went to Frosty's with my grandson and his girlfriend on a warm afternoon. I lived on Broadway 2 blocks away in 2004-2014 so I took my grandson many times for ice cream here he was 4 when I 1st...
Sabra R.
7/1/2025
Sorry no photo, too busy eating! Love the soft serve and the portions are gigantic! Always have a long list of Perry's ice cream you don't see anywhere else. Cute old gas station building and...
Tammy J.
8/31/2024
Oogie Boogie approves! Came at the right time as it just got done raining and there was no one there. Perfect little treat with so many different options. As always, service was great and cashier...
Amelia W.
7/5/2024
I have been a regular at both Frosty's locations for many years. They offer flavors you can't find anywhere else, especially when it comes to frozen custard. And their cones are quite large. I'm a...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.