Fly by Night Cookie

Permanently closed
yelp logo

(12)

Photos

[9943 - 9999] Fancher Rd
Brewerton, NY 13029

Also at this address

Reviews

yelp logo
4.012 reviews
Photo of Jerry M.
Jerry M.
9/29/2020

I save five stars for someplace special. This is such a place, I mean, how can you NOT check out a business with a name like Fly By Night Cookies? First of all, I admire people who have an idea...

Photo of janice c.
janice c.
9/7/2022

Cookies are sometimes a bit dry but we still love it there. The building is so cute! The one problem is parking...but we manage. A great addition to Fair Haven!!!

Photo of Debra R.
Debra R.
6/25/2020

Is there a ZERO rating or -1 ??? Outdoors smelled like dog urine, inside cookie room smelled like mildew. Barking dogs behind a curtain. Ugh!

Andrew W.
9/6/2022

Very cool and quaint little shop. The cookies are amazing and so is the tiny little village and decorations. Very fun place to stop and visit.

Photo of Alisha W.
Alisha W.
8/29/2018

Love love this place. Went this weekend, fresh, like still hot, cookies kids were enthralled with the miniature "museum" and I'm not a baker, so hot fresh deliciousness, yes please take my money...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesNew YorkBrewertonFly by Night Cookie