Nancy G.
9/27/2025
Ice cream was great; Alma was even greater. 10/10 no notes, would definitely come back!!
Five Pennies Creamery
Closed
(15)
Photos
288 Main St
Beacon, NY 12508
Five Pennies Creamery, the brainchild of Dan Levine, is a beloved ice cream shop that embodies the spirit of a classic New York mom-and-pop establishment. Named after the film "The Five Pennies," the creamery emphasizes the importance of love and community over corporate pretensions, offering over 100 homemade ice cream flavors made on-site.
After a brief closure in December 2022, Five Pennies Creamery has reopened in May 2024 at Hudson Valley Food Hall in Beacon, NY. With a diverse menu that includes specialty items like milkshakes and ice cream pies, the creamery continues to delight customers with its rich, high-quality offerings and commitment to serving the community.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.515 reviews
Jason P.
4/25/2025
Five Pennies Creamery is the first place you see when you walk into the Hudson Valley Food Hall. And the last. I walked into the Market for iced coffee. I had just eaten. I wasn't hungry. At...
Bonnie G.
7/28/2024
Really good! Get the feeling all their flavors are great. Tastes homemade, full of flavor, not chemicals. They didn't have their famed cookie dough flavor today, so we got their butterfinger and...
Lauren G.
9/4/2024
When I saw the sign for homemade ice cream while at the library, we made a beeline for Five Pennies. Dan was very cordial as he shared a bit about making ice cream as well as many delicious...
Amy P.
6/4/2024
What a great ice cream place! I stopped in during the Beacon food crawl and met the owner. He told me how he made the ice cream. What a great guy and what an amazing product! I ended up getting...
See a problem?