Steven G.
8/10/2025
Servers and Bartenders and live music keep the energy on hot summer days. I'll have my sunshine with a Cubano and a Montauk Summer Ale, please?
fatfish on The Water
$$$
Closed
(400)
Photos
28 Cottage Ave
Bay Shore, NY 11706
History
Started in 2004 and revitalized an historic landmark in Bay Shore, and becoming one of Long Island's greatest seafood restaurants.
Specialties
Fresh Seafood with Mediterranean influences and featuring Coastal American Docks supplying us daily. Live Music and daily happy hour
Also at this address
Reviews
3.5400 reviews
Christina S.
7/11/2025
Fat Fish has been around forever and is a perfect summer spot with spectacular views. Eat on the outdoor deck for sure!! The service was great, food was amazing and the atmosphere is gorgeous....
Rod N.
9/10/2025
Portions are small and over priced. For example: I ordered for main course Tuna with Crab tempura cost $42 and only one tiny tempura crab leg the size of my child's pinkie finger. The side order...
Grace Y.
7/20/2025
1 star for the drink margarita. 1 star for the food cheesecake which tastes very generic and crab cake. The octopus was alright. The calama batter was decent but the sauce tastes very from a...
Vivian R.
8/2/2025
It's alway nice to dining outside in the summer time. Live Music is always is a plus. Reservations are recommended plus additional time is needed for outdoor dining. Service is alway outstanding...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.