TAndra P.
6/17/2025
I had a craving for pasta and said what's better than going to an Italian spot. My friend told me about this spot and it's absolutely gorgeous. The ambiance, the food gives a homey and cozy feel....
Destefano's Old Erie
$$
Open
(131)
Photos
7 W Main St
Middletown, NY 10940
The Olde Erie Pub, located in Middletown, NY, is a popular dining destination offering a diverse menu and exceptional catering services. With a commitment to providing a memorable experience, they specialize in customizing menus to suit any occasion.
As a part of the Mid-Hudson Region of New York, The Olde Erie Pub closely follows developments related to the Novel Corona Virus, ensuring the safety and well-being of their patrons. With a scannable QR code for easy access to their dinner menu, this pub is known for its warm ambiance and friendly service.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.5131 reviewsRalph H.
10/30/2025
If you're in search of old school family Italian cuisine like I was , then your quest is over . Having only been in the Middletown area for a couple of weeks , Destefano's restaurant's reputation...
Robert G.
4/15/2025
Oyster were fresh, vongole was tremendous, and the chicken was so tender but crispy really enjoyed ourselves, always a pleasure to go there
Maria B.
7/29/2025
DeStefano's Old Erie is a gem in Middletown. The food is fresh and delicious (scratch kitchen), and the portions are huge. I never leave without a doggie bag. The restaurant is beautifully...
Jo-Ann C.
7/29/2025
Among my favorite restaurants in Middletown. There is something for everyone on the menu.Food is fresh and delicious with generous portions, staff is friendly and efficient, and often a fun...
See a problem?
