Queen R.
10/20/2025
Pizza quality has seriously leveled up -- the crust, sauce, and overall flavor are on point. The eggplant topping is a standout: tender, rich, and perfectly balanced with the rest of the pie....
Delmar Pizzeria
$
Closed
(282)
Photos
1668 Sheepshead Bay Rd
Brooklyn, NY 11235
Delmar Pizzeria and Italian Restaurant has been serving the residents of Sheepshead Bay since 1957 and is the originator of the "white pizza." Along with our famous pizza pies, our loyal customers also enjoy our salads, heroes, pastas, seafood and specialty pies...
Reviews
4.0282 reviews
Michelle K.
11/9/2025
Always delicious! This neighborhood pizzeria never disappoints. Great quality, great flavor, and the perfect spot for a reliable, tasty slice.
Christy Y.
3/1/2025
I thought I knew great pizza until I tried Delmar Pizzeria. I stopped by on a weekend for lunch, just before the crowd hit, and ended up ordering two slices of plain cheese pizza and a chicken...
Samantha V.
10/4/2025
They are awesome and always were. Hands down, nothing bad here. Pizza is delicious and the plates are perfect. They haven't changed at all. Quality and consistency.
Tyrone F.
11/5/2025
You standing on line and the guy is so busy he takes people who just walk in. Terrible service I would not recommend him to my enemy.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.