Kathleen J.
8/2/2025
My favorite go to place in Bay Shore I'm so glad they opened. Frozen daiquiris(my absolute fav) to great specials to the amazing staff. Outstanding experiences every time I dine. Still to this day...
Dark Horse Tavern
Closed
(6)
Photos
53 W Main St
Bay Shore, NY 11706
Dark Horse Tavern in Bay Shore NY is a lively neighborhood bar known for its welcoming atmosphere and diverse drink selection. With a mix of classic cocktails local craft beers and tasty pub fare it’s a perfect spot for friends to gather. The tavern often hosts live music and events making it a vibrant destination for both locals and visitors looking to unwind and enjoy a great night out.
Generated from this place's information
Also at this address
Reviews
3.56 reviewsJon P.
10/30/2025
Dark horse is trash, all of the locations are dumps, food is bad, vibe is bad. Corks and taps was such a better fit for the strip
Cassandra V.
6/14/2025
Picture of the security guard after he touched and pushed my sister out of the bar. Do not recommend.
Vicki G.
5/10/2025
Great food and drinks. We sat at the table outside on the sidewalk. Very attentive staff.
Kim M.
6/15/2025
Great service however, the food was horrible. I wanted it to be good. Disappointed. Will not go back.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.