Michael D.
9/1/2025
Pancakes were out of this world!! Staff were amazing as well. Will definitely go back
Crooked Lake Ice Cream Company
$
Open
(76)
Photos
33 Shether St
Hammondsport, NY 14840
At Crooked Lake Ice Cream Co., we strive to create a family friendly environment where the 21st century meets the style and comfort of a classic 50s diner. Take an ice cream or coffee to go on the way out - Keuka Lake is only a 2-minute walk from our shop! It doesn't get much better than that. We’ll see you soon!
Also at this address
Reviews
4.076 reviews
Brian G.
8/21/2025
You had me at ice cream for breakfast!! Don't let the name fool you, this little chic joint in Hammondsport is a lot more than just ice cream. We went for breakfast and were very happy we did....
Gina C.
8/4/2025
We got seated pretty quickly, and our drinks came out without a hitch, so things started off strong. Unfortunately, the wait for our food was over 30 minutes, which was a bit frustrating. When we...
Mat G.
6/28/2025
Delightful ice cream in an old school ice cream parlor setting! The whole experience was reminiscent of books that I would read that were set in the early 20th century whereas characters would...
Betty K.
10/16/2025
Was in town for the Wineglass Marathon and found this super cute spot for lunch! Friendly staff and the food hit the spot. I must return for the ice cream!
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.