Bryon T.
6/23/2025
Sunset Beach Hotel was such a vibe! The aesthetics of this place had me feeling like I was in Costa Rica. Such a cool place. The drinks are expensive, but that's probably to be expected. It...
Cresent Beach
Permanently closed
(239)
Photos
35 Shore Rd
Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
See why so many travelers make Sunset Beach their hotel of choice when visiting Shelter Island. Providing an ideal mix of value, comfort and convenience, it offers a romantic setting with an array of amenities designed for travelers like you.
Guest rooms offer amenities such as a flat screen TV and air conditioning, and guests can go online with free wifi offered by the hotel.
Sunset Beach Hotel features room service, a concierge, and shops, to help make your stay more enjoyable. The property also boasts an on-site restaurant. If you are driving to Sunset Beach Hotel, free parking is available.
For those interested in checking out Shelter Island Historical Society (1.9 mi) while visiting Shelter Island, Sunset Beach Hotel is a short distance away.
During your visit, be sure to check out one of Shelter Island's popular shrimp restaurants such as Commander Cody's, Vine Street Cafe, and Salt, all a short distance from Sunset Beach Hotel.
There is no shortage of things to do in the area: explore popular gardens such as Sylvester Manor Educational Farm.
We’re sure you’ll enjoy your stay at Sunset Beach as you experience all of the things Shelter Island has to offer.
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0239 reviewsGianna C.
8/12/2025
My mother and I have been doing a mother-daughter trip at this hotel every summer for years, and we were looking forward to this one. Unfortunately, the experience fell short. Several staff...
Anna R.
8/12/2024
Every year I make a point to return to sunset beach ! Love it here makes me feel like a bit like I've traveled abroad and it seems every year there's a new manger at the restaurant I've met quite...
Cyrus P.
7/18/2022
The staff really did their best to stay out of the way when needed, be in the way when wanted and pretty much get you anything you might need at a whim. Tesla & EV chargers available. Nate,...
Pamela M.
8/26/2023
Not worth the hype. Got a glass at the bar & when seated at the table, they forgot my 2nd glass of rosé. Everyone else got their drink. I asked 3x!!!! Seriously. Then gave me a small pour...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.