Coyle's Ice Cream

$
Open
yelp logo

(90)

Photos

509 Main St
Islip, NY 11751
Homemade ice cream serving 25 flavors.Enjoy a cone or a sundae at one of our booths or sit out back at the picnic table listening to music.

Also at this address

Reviews

yelp logo
4.090 reviews
Photo of Pamela J.
Pamela J.
9/22/2025

If they had fresh whipped cream, I'd have given them 5 stars. Flavors were awesome and soft serve excellent. It's cute and old fashioned inside to make a perfect date night scene. Girl behind...

Photo of Chip P.
Chip P.
7/14/2025

Small old school cream shop feel. Never too busy. Staff I've encountered has been young and not too into service. But they have a great range of amazing flavors and don't skimp on the toppings....

Photo of Debora F.
Debora F.
9/7/2025

Tons of ice cream options. The space is small but has booths available -- our party of four fit comfortably. The ice cream was delicious and the service was good!

K R.
8/9/2025

The Islip location has been a long time favorite of mine because the ice cream is delicious. I even go there on the coldest of winter days because I love it that much. The only downside is the...

Photo of Maria G.
Maria G.
2/5/2025

Very sweet worker who was patient while we took some time to decide amongst the MANY flavors. Cherry vanilla, black raspberry, banana Oreo, and strawberry crunch were all so delicious!...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesNew YorkCoyle's Ice Cream

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.