Cow Over the Moon

$$
Open
yelp logo

(13)

Call
Website

Photos

282 Main St
Huntington, NY 11743
+1 (631) 424-1796
http://toysonmainstreet.com

Cow Over the Moon in Huntington, NY offers a diverse selection of toys, sports memorabilia, baby gifts, and unique items for all ages.

Originally specializing in sports memorabilia, the store expanded in 2011 to include popular toy brands like Fisher Price and Melissa & Doug, providing a one-stop shop for a variety of gift options.

Generated from their available business information

Also at this address

Reviews

yelp logo
4.013 reviews
Photo of Fox E.
Fox E.
8/25/2019

I prefer Pig Under The Sun, but this will do. There's nothing at all wrong with this little family owned toy store and if you see some of the negative reviews here - especially when they're...

Read more on Yelp
brb b.
9/26/2022

Really cute toy store. A huge selection of everything the kids could want: puzzles, action figures, coloring, legos, etc. everything was neatly organized, the AC was working, and the store...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Amy E.
Amy E.
10/6/2019

Very helpful and have a wide assortment of toys! Every time I have called to check if they have a toy they always do. Asked for some help picking out a gift and apparently the worker knocked it...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Diana P.
Diana P.
8/11/2019

Great store! Brian is so great and helpful to everyone. If you're looking for awesome hard to find sports memorabilia, this is the place.

Read more on Yelp
Dennis C.
11/25/2021

Best toy store I have seen in ages. I will be back. It's a grandfather's place to buy! Got many good items for a fair price

Read more on Yelp
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Awnings, Automotive wrecking for scrap

Monmouth County Awning Co

Monmouth Ocean County Awning, established in 1940, has been proudly serving the New Jersey shore area with high-quality awnings and custom shade solutions. Located in Asbury Park, the company specializes in manufacturing retractable awnings, valences, canopies, and curtains tailored to meet individual needs and specifications. In addition to their custom products, Monmouth Ocean County Awning offers seasonal takedown and installation services, along with winter storage options. Their commitment to quality and customer satisfaction has made them a trusted name in the local community for over eight decades. Generated from the website
Wrestling Universe
Trading cards: baseball or other sports, entertainment, etc., Comic books

Wrestling Universe

22
•
$$
"If you love pro wrestling. This is the store for you. Figures and autographed items for days. Wrestlers appear here very often to do signings that are open to the public (wrestlers will sign..."
photo of Kevin G.
American Legends
Trading cards: baseball or other sports, entertainment, etc., Collectibles and antiques, mail order, Comic books

American Legends

18
•
$$$
"There is no more Complete Card Shop in the area. Hands Down. The BEST place to, not only get cards, but your supplies as well. The whole staff, not just the owners, are knowledgeable and always..."
photo of Anthony L.
United States›New York›Huntington›Cow Over the Moon

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.