Susan B.
10/31/2025
Lovely you store. Great selection and hands-on help ! So nice to have a local Shop to browse and get input and help from salespeople.
Cow Over the Moon
$$
Closed
(14)
Photos
282 Main St
Huntington, NY 11743
Cow Over the Moon Toys Sports Memorabilia has been a staple in Huntington, NY, for over 16 years, offering a wide selection of toys, sports memorabilia, and gifts. The store features a variety of renowned brands, including Melissa & Doug, LEGO, and Fisher Price, as well as certified autographed sports items from trusted distributors like Steiner Sports and PSA DNA.
In 2011, the store expanded by acquiring an established toy store that had served the community for more than 24 years. Committed to customer satisfaction, Cow Over the Moon provides complimentary gift wrapping for all purchases and also offers services for buying sports memorabilia from collectors.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.014 reviews
Fox E.
8/25/2019
I prefer Pig Under The Sun, but this will do. There's nothing at all wrong with this little family owned toy store and if you see some of the negative reviews here - especially when they're...
brb b.
9/26/2022
Really cute toy store. A huge selection of everything the kids could want: puzzles, action figures, coloring, legos, etc. everything was neatly organized, the AC was working, and the store...
Amy E.
10/6/2019
Very helpful and have a wide assortment of toys! Every time I have called to check if they have a toy they always do. Asked for some help picking out a gift and apparently the worker knocked it...
Diana P.
8/11/2019
Great store! Brian is so great and helpful to everyone. If you're looking for awesome hard to find sports memorabilia, this is the place.
See a problem?
