Lynn A.
11/12/2025
Still love my Coney Island hot dogs, their sauce the best in the world, IMHO ! Their French fries still rock! Their coleslaw is equal to the best in Middletown. Their chef is same from some...
Coney Island Cafe
$
Closed
(33)
Photos
10 Railroad Ave
Middletown, NY 10940
Coney Island Cafe in Middletown, NY, is a popular destination renowned for its vibrant selection of food offerings. The cafe creates a welcoming atmosphere, ideal for enjoying delicious meals in the heart of the community.
With its unique blend of flavors and a commitment to quality, Coney Island Cafe has become a cherished spot for locals and visitors alike. Its dedication to providing a delightful dining experience sets it apart in the competitive culinary landscape of Middletown.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
2.533 reviews
Tanya J.
4/27/2024
I placed my order 30 mins before opening with the app. The food was not as expected tho the homemade corn beef hash tasted like day old sat in a fridge without being covered. The over medium eggs...
Linda S.
2/9/2023
What a great place! I was looking for something other than a diner breakfast and found CIC online. I'm so glad I did. Hubby and I stopped for breakfast after an appointment. The banana bread...
Israel M.
2/13/2024
Not what it claims to be. I thought I would get a great hotdogs but I got something soggy n tasteless. Will not go there again! IFrench fries we're good. Service was good. Rest was drappy and not...
Erby L.
8/10/2023
Poor customer service with the new lady at the front. She is not friendly like the other people that was there.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.