Kim C.
11/5/2025
Food is always fresh and delicious! If you are lucky enough you get to meet Commander Cody ( not his real name) The Commander's daughter does most of the cooking and baking all delicious. Try the...
Commander Cody's Seafood
$$
Open
(85)
Photos
41 Smith St
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Commander Cody's Seafood is a quaint restaurant nestled in Shelter Island, NY, known for its fresh seafood offerings and casual dining atmosphere.
With a focus on locally sourced ingredients and a menu featuring classic seafood dishes, Commander Cody's Seafood provides a relaxed dining experience for both locals and visitors alike.
Generated from their business information
Also at this address
Reviews
3.585 reviews
TJ J.
8/24/2024
Food was decent. Fish was seasoned and fried well done as per my request. Lobster roll was the perfect size not too much and not so little. Service was amazing and this place is black owned so it...
K L.
9/8/2024
Came here for lunch on a weekday and it was pretty quiet. A no-frills ambiance which was totally fine; food was good and they of course used high-quality seafood. You order at the counter,...
Paul S.
8/3/2025
Yes, it's got a cool vibe, good music. We had fish and chips, the fish was fresh and very good, and the fries were also very good; and we had a great lobster roll. Service is essentially...
Stanley C.
9/26/2025
Awesome food - pan fried chicken! Such a good and easy option on the island- make sure you bring cash!
See a problem?
