Giovanni D.
10/16/2025
One of the best local pizzeria's Port Jeff has to offer. What I really like about this joint is the simplicity. Pizza. No if's, and's, or buts. No salad, no pasta, just pizza. Honestly, I think...
Colosseo Pizza
$
Open
(390)
Photos
1049 Route 112
Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776
Colosseo Pizza, a family-owned establishment since 1980, is a beloved pizzeria located in Port Jefferson Station, NY. Known for its mouth-watering pizza and fresh salads, the restaurant prides itself on providing a casual dining experience with prompt service and attractive prices.
With a cozy atmosphere and a dedicated staff, Colosseo Pizza has earned a reputation as one of the best pizzerias on Long Island. Many patrons return regularly, drawn by the quality of the food and the welcoming environment that has made it a local favorite for decades.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0390 reviews
Frances P.
10/28/2025
I haven't asked for a side of sauce since the debacle but I just wanted to say, the knots aren't trash, they're actually pretty good esp when they add extra oil to the plate so you can dip em. I...
Gabrielle G.
9/12/2025
This place is very popular and was crowded just after 5pm on a Friday night. They have a limited menu selection but are good at what they make. The pizzas we ordered were tasty but not fabulous....
Jean T.
1/1/2025
Service was efficient, if not cheery. This is a large pizza place in a strip mall. There's counter seating for slices in the front, restaurant seating in the back. I had one cheese slice and one...
Michael Anthony C.
10/18/2025
Had a salad slice and a Sicilian slice, 4 hours later was sick with apparent food poisoning. Admitted to Stony Brook for 10 days with ecoli. Very serious. Unfortunately will never go back
See a problem?
