Giovanni D.
10/16/2025
One of the best local pizzeria's Port Jeff has to offer. What I really like about this joint is the simplicity. Pizza. No if's, and's, or buts. No salad, no pasta, just pizza. Honestly, I think...
Colosseo Pizza
$
Closed
(392)
Photos
1049 Route 112
Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776
Colosseo Pizza, a family-owned establishment since 1980, is a beloved pizzeria located in Port Jefferson Station, NY. Known for its mouth-watering pizza and fresh salads, the restaurant prides itself on providing a casual dining experience with prompt service and attractive prices.
With a cozy atmosphere and a dedicated staff, Colosseo Pizza has earned a reputation as one of the best pizzerias on Long Island. Many patrons return regularly, drawn by the quality of the food and the welcoming environment that has made it a local favorite for decades.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0392 reviews
Bret H.
11/11/2025
Great pizza! The flavors were spot on, the crust was perfectly baked, and the location made it an easy favorite. Can't wait to come back for another slice!
Frances P.
10/28/2025
I haven't asked for a side of sauce since the debacle but I just wanted to say, the knots aren't trash, they're actually pretty good esp when they add extra oil to the plate so you can dip em. I...
Jean T.
1/1/2025
Service was efficient, if not cheery. This is a large pizza place in a strip mall. There's counter seating for slices in the front, restaurant seating in the back. I had one cheese slice and one...
Gabrielle G.
9/12/2025
This place is very popular and was crowded just after 5pm on a Friday night. They have a limited menu selection but are good at what they make. The pizzas we ordered were tasty but not fabulous....
See a problem?
