Mark II S.
6/28/2025
I considered a Five Star review for Colony Seafood & Steakhouse but just a couple of small issues prevented a full five star rating. This is a hidden gem not far from the Sunset Bay beach bar...
Colony
$$
Closed
(44)
Photos
876 Main Rd
Irving, NY 14081
Colony Seafood and Steakhouse, established in 1982 by the LaBarbera family, is a hidden gem in Western New York, renowned for its commitment to quality Italian-American cuisine. With a menu featuring over 45 staple dishes and daily specials, the restaurant emphasizes fresh ingredients and exceptional service.
Owner and head chef Jeff LaBarbera has cultivated strong relationships with quality distributors, ensuring that the value of these partnerships is reflected in the dining experience. Guests are invited to enjoy a fine dining atmosphere at unbeatable prices, making Colony a must-visit destination for food enthusiasts.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.044 reviews
Erin H.
1/6/2025
I've been here a few times since my first review, and the Colony deserved better from me. The steaks here are always cooked to perfection. Their appetizers are delicious- we usually get the pork...
Cyndi P.
6/29/2025
Service is always top notch. Wait staff are knowledgeable and friendly. During the summer season I would say it's a good idea to have reservations but they will try to accommodate you. The...
Bill S.
8/11/2025
what used to be "fine dining" is now a truck stop. Food still great but atmosphere lacking as half people dressed like slobs, tee shirts, dirty shorts, tank tops hats on backwards. Come on man...
Jill W.
8/24/2024
Service was excellent. Food was excellent. Bar was excellent. Time waiting for food was a bit, but worth it. Fettuccine Alfredo with chicken, NY strip with mushrooms, and Veal Parmigiana all were...
See a problem?
