Anh P.
10/20/2025
Decent bakery for sweets tooth. I had their pies 3 times, overall they were good. The banana cream pie had the strong banana food flavor in it which I didn't enjoy much, other pies were good. They...
Colby's Ice Cream & Bake Shop
$
Closed
(60)
Photos
7272 W Henrietta Rd
Rush, NY 14543
Colby's Ice Cream & Bake Shop is a charming eatery located in Rush NY known for its delightful selection of homemade ice cream and freshly baked goods. The cozy atmosphere invites families and friends to gather while enjoying a variety of flavors and treats. Whether you're in the mood for a scoop of creamy ice cream or a delicious pastry Colby's is the perfect spot to satisfy your sweet tooth.
Generated from this place's information
Also at this address
Reviews
3.560 reviewsJinna S.
10/3/2025
I have tasted dirt more inspiring than the food here. The food is literally raw too. The atmosphere is not visually appealing whatsoever. I would not send the descendants of my worst enemy here.
Jennifer D.
9/14/2024
I love supporting local. This is a great local bakery, ice cream shop, and bbq joint all in one. I have had their fry cakes before, and they were great with a cup of coffee. Today, I got a...
Earl R.
10/1/2025
Purchased Colby's grape pie at Naples Grape fest. Couldn't wait to tuck in. Ugh! No actual grapes in the filling. Rather a thick, rubbery pudding-like paste made of grape juice and cornstarch....
L. C.
8/31/2025
I bought a very small strawberry rhubarb pie for my husband at Greece Farm Market for $8.00. Totally disappointed. Bitter. No visible strawberries and barely any rhubarb. Crust looked amazing, but...
See a problem?
