Amanda T.
8/17/2025
we went after they were taken over by la slice and the owner is the nicest guy ever we accidentally ordered to the wrong location and he opened up the store after they were closed and made us a...
Classico Pizzeria
$$
Open
(24)
Photos
5 Udall Rd
West Islip, NY 11795
Classico Pizzeria, located in West Islip, NY, is a dining establishment offering a variety of pizza options and Italian cuisine. The restaurant encourages patrons to reach out directly for inquiries and reservations.
In the event of any issues with their online presence, patrons are reminded that they can also explore other local dining options through nearby restaurant listings. Classico Pizzeria is dedicated to providing a delightful dining experience for its community.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.024 reviews
Dyamond D.
10/28/2024
4.5 stars! Just went here for the first time and I was pleasantly surprised. Some of the pizzerias in the area aren't great and I saw that they have a chicken caesar salad slice so I decided to...
Bill C.
7/9/2025
What happened to this place? When they first opened and for a while they had pretty good pizza and good service. The last few visits were very disappointing. The pizza was terrible and service...
Kerri B.
11/28/2023
This is our favorite pizzeria, the food is great! I swear, we are here on a bi-weekly basis! Our first visit was for the Eggplant Ala Vodka rolls (ask for extra Vodka sauce for dipping on the...
Michael S.
8/10/2024
Everything! First when I called person was kinda rude! 2nd messed up order 3rd food was at best was ok 4th chicken parm hero, chicken was hard! Ordered a wrap dressing was supposed to be on the...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.