Olivia R.
8/9/2025
I have never, ever written a Yelp review in my life. However, I just left City Island Pizza Company, and I feel inspired -- NO, compelled to write this review. And here's what I have to say. I...
City Island Pizza Company llc
$$
Closed
(23)
Photos
273 City Island Ave Fl Grd
Bronx, NY 10464
City Island Pizza Company LLC is a vibrant dining establishment located in the picturesque town of City Island, often referred to as the Nantucket of the Bronx. The restaurant offers a unique blend of nautical and mid-century decor, featuring a carefully curated wine list, authentic Italian cuisine, and a commitment to warm hospitality.
Dedicated to quality and community, City Island Pizza Co. utilizes locally sourced ingredients to craft dishes that honor their Italian roots while embracing the New York setting. With options for group dining and catering, the restaurant provides customizable event experiences that reflect its gracious service and strong community ties.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
5.023 reviews
Billy F.
9/13/2025
City Island Pizza Company is truly a hidden gem! The thin-crust pizza is absolutely delicious--my parents had been here a few times and raved about it, and they were right. While they don't serve...
Yoav J.
10/12/2025
Nice spot on CI that I appreciate had a decent vegan option! Service can be a bit slow for food depending how busy they are, but pizza is pizza. Would get again if I am in the area but wouldn't...
Lillian E.
3/3/2025
When I tell you this place has the best eggplant parmigiana and pizza believe me. Their calamari pizza is so nice and fresh and I love the crunch crust. The eggplant parmigiana is so yummy and...
Alex Dallas M.
7/11/2024
I had been eyeing this place since it opened up. Since our first visit we have gone 3 times and every time it has been great. Once you walk in you are greeted warmly by the staff. I have gone on...
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.