Nicole M.
4/28/2025
The cookies are amazing. However they should stick to cookies, I ordered cupcakes and they were so dense they were more like the texture of a pound cake. Also, the cupcake to frosting ratio was...
Cheryl's Cookies
(33)
Photos
1 Old Country Rd
Carle Place, NY 11514
Cheryl's Cookies in Carle Place, NY, is a local bakery specializing in a variety of freshly baked cookies.
With a focus on quality ingredients and traditional recipes, Cheryl's Cookies offers a selection of sweet treats for customers to enjoy.
Generated from their business information
Also at this address
Reviews
1.533 reviews
Jobeth E.
11/27/2024
Horrible service. No communication and alternative options are not great either. I'm really not sure how this business is still in business with most of the reviews not being favorable.
Cheryl Mathis ..
9/24/2025
Have used Cheryls cookies for several years past. No problem. Tried to use them recently and HORRIBLE SERVICE. One order was randomly cancelled without notice. Another order got stuck in Ohio...
Stacy M.
9/10/2025
I absolutely love the cookies, unfortunately their delivery is terrible. I have placed 2 orders from them in the last 5 months, and both orders were "lost" or said delivered, and never got to me....
Sandra O.
1/11/2025
Run....Don't walk from this company!!! I ordered a box of cookies in December as a Congratulations gift for someone. I was told it would be delivered Jan- 4 to 6. I had no choice but to wait. It...
See a problem?
