Carter's Creamery

Feels like spring but tastes like summer! We tried out this family-owned creamery in Cazenovia during their grand opening weekend. We already can't wait to go back! Pros: delicious milkshakes,...

Soft serve was "ok". Lower butterfat % than Byrne dairy and many other ice cream places in the area. Soft serve mix is rated by percentage of butterfat and it goes from 3.5% to around 14%. Some...

They should consider moving their menu - it was impossible to read it with the sun's glare. Customer service was underwhelming and my milkshake came out 10 minutes after everyone else's did with...

Stopped by here with my sister. She got the fruity pebbles milkshake and I got the peanut butter pretzel ice cream in a chocolate dipped waffle cone. She really liked her shake and the peanut...

The hard ice cream was delicious - peanut butter pretzel especially. Creamy and crunchy chocolate covered pretzel. The service was also very fast and friendly. There was a good sized line when we...