Carroll Gardens Classic Diner

Permanently closed
yelp logo

(158)

Photos

155 Smith St
Brooklyn, NY 11201

Reviews

yelp logo
3.0158 reviews
Photo of Robby E.
Robby E.
4/22/2021

They were great, and now they're gone. Another victim of the stupidity of the Trump administration's limp-dick response to the international pandemic. Well loved and truly missed.

Photo of Nessa R.
Nessa R.
6/29/2020

Carroll's is known for their 24 hour diner but Covid has affected their hours. I finally made it after work. I got the chicken parmigiana. It was good. Not sure I'd get it again. Big portions...

Photo of Johanna B.
Johanna B.
9/26/2020

They are permanently closed. With the ongoing list of Covid affected businesses, this diner has seen its last days and closed their doors. My review is based on the numerous times I have visited...

Photo of Anna X.
Anna X.
7/14/2018

Attention all night owls... this diner is open 24 hours!!!!! If you're ever craving anything familiar and comforting at inconvenient hours of the night (or if you're one and a half beers in from...

Photo of Eden M.
Eden M.
7/14/2020

I so appreciate this diner existing in this overpriced strip of Brooklyn. They always have dependable soups, grilled cheese, and burgers, and really nice waitstaff. I take one star off because the...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesNew YorkBrooklynCarroll Gardens Classic Diner

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Online ordering by Grubhub.com.

Partial Data by Foursquare.