Julia L.
9/3/2019
My friend and I were planning to go to The Smith for breakfast but by the time we got there, breakfast wasn't served anymore. We bumped into Carol's Cafe and it was the thank goodness we didnt pay...
Carol's Cafe
$
Closed
(59)
Photos
217 E 51st St
New York, NY 10022
Carol's Cafe is a cozy eatery in the heart of New York, NY that offers a diverse menu of comfort food and specialty drinks.
With a welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff, Carol's Cafe is a popular spot for locals and visitors looking for a casual dining experience.
Generated from their business information
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.059 reviews
Zac M.
9/5/2025
This is a small service counter. The food was pretty mid, but fairly inexpensive. The seating was super nice in an outdoor area with a waterfall.
Jim C.
6/25/2025
We stayed at POD51 across the street and found this gem! A small urban park with a lovely waterfall feature. Carol's classic western omelette breakfast with a smoothie was great and inexpensive!
Melissa B.
10/15/2024
Delicious breakfast sandwiches!! Our terrace overlooks the park where it is located so we see people eating there all of the time and smell the amazing aroma of the food!! Such a peaceful place to...
Emi G.
11/22/2022
Incredible! Tucked away, with a beautiful waterfall and quaint seating, Carol's is a hidden gem! The food is so reasonable and absolutely delicious. Went for Essa-Bagel and the line was too long....
See a problem?
