Stephanie F.
10/25/2025
If you haven't been to Carmela's yet - go! It is easily one of the best local, family owned spots around. From the moment you walk in, you're greeted with warmth and genuine hospitality from...
Carmela's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Permanently closed
(125)
Photos
4151 Merrick Rd
Massapequa, NY 11758
Carmela's Pizzeria & Restaurant, a cherished establishment in Massapequa, NY, has been serving the community since 1981 with authentic Italian cuisine infused with heartfelt hospitality. With a legacy built on quality food and exceptional service, they cater to various events, from intimate gatherings to grand celebrations, ensuring memorable experiences for all guests.
Known for their generous portions and time-honored recipes, Carmela's is an ideal venue for special occasions, including birthdays, corporate events, and holiday parties. Offering both dine-in and catering services, they strive to create unforgettable moments while honoring their rich history and commitment to family and community.
Generated from the website
Reviews
4.5125 reviews
John F.
10/30/2025
I am volunteer for Big Brother Big Sister and my little likes to get pizza every outing so I have been sampling a lot of different pizza places the past 8 months. The last 2 I went to were...
Matt G.
10/25/2025
Best pizza and best owners. Been going here for 15 years after stumbling upon it rushing off to a game. Great pizza and food. And since I need 85 characters I like there pizza very very very very...
Stephanie F.
10/25/2025
If you haven't been to Carmela's yet - go! It is easily one of the best local, family owned spots around. From the moment you walk in, you're greeted with warmth and genuine hospitality from...
Karen J.
9/23/2025
I had a wonderful dining experience at Carmela's-- everything from the atmosphere to the food was top-notch!
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.