Russell O.
9/12/2025
Food is amazing and so tasty with great presentation. Services were excellent, making you feel at home , went above and beyond to make our dining experience a special one. The ambiance is so warm...
Carmela's Pizza Restaurant
$$
Closed
(73)
Photos
1021 State Route 17K
Montgomery, NY 12549
Carmela's Pizza Restaurant, located in Montgomery, NY, has been serving authentic Italian cuisine since 1975, offering a warm and welcoming atmosphere that makes diners feel right at home. Known for its family-style dining, Carmela's is a perfect spot for both weeknight dinners and special occasions, bringing people together over delicious meals and pizza.
In addition to its dine-in experience, Carmela's provides convenient takeout options and a diverse catering menu ideal for gatherings of any size. With consistently praised dishes and attentive service, Carmela's continues to impress guests, making it a beloved local gem for Italian food enthusiasts.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.573 reviews
Daniel A.
5/2/2025
Not my first rodeo here, overall good. Food/Drink: Pizza by the slice! Pretty good New York style pizza. Good amount of options and combos. Full Italian style menu, appetizers, entrees, pizza,...
Krista L.
10/3/2025
First time I tried this restaurant, the food was good. I tried their pizza not too long after and it was good. Not great. But good. I went back and ordered the same meal, chicken parm. The chicken...
Devin C.
4/11/2025
Wow these garlic knots were amazing! The service was fast and attentive, and the location felt cozy!
Kevin M.
12/6/2024
I missed this place when they had the fire. The owners were always there and the food and service were on point. Since they reopened after the fire I've been back twice and they have lost...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.