Mike D.
8/31/2025
Stopped by on my way out east for a quick lunch had the chicken parmigiana was one the best I highly recommend Carlos pizza and restaurant.
Carlo's Pizzeria & Restorante
$$
Closed
(135)
Photos
451 Glen Dr
Shirley, NY 11967
Carlo's Pizzeria & Ristorante, a family-owned establishment since 1986, takes pride in offering quality Italian cuisine in Shirley, NY. Their menu boasts a diverse selection, featuring seafood dishes, rolls, calzones, various styles of pizza, hero sandwiches, pasta dishes, and classic Italian favorites like Campagnola and Parmigiana. Customers can also enjoy paninis, soups, salads, and a range of gluten-free options, ensuring there's something for every craving.
With over 30 years of experience, Carlo's has become a local favorite for those seeking authentic Italian flavors. From Neapolitan to Sicilian and Deep Dish Pizzas, each dish is prepared with care and dedication. Whether you're in the mood for a hearty meal or a quick bite, Carlo's offers a welcoming atmosphere where families can come together to enjoy delicious food made with love.
Generated from the website content
Also at this address
Reviews
3.0135 reviewsPamela C.
9/9/2025
I don't know what possesses me to keep going back to this pizzeria. I think because it's close and I work all day and I don't feel like hiking it anyway but this was the final straw. I'm tired. I...
R C.
7/19/2025
I also have been a customer for a long time. Sorry to say food and service has gone down over the years. The staff has no clue about food safety. Frank the new owner is clueless about how to run...
Linda H.
6/3/2025
we have been going to Carlos for close to 20 years. not sure what has happened recently but the food quality has been awful. we got a spaghetti and meatballs dinner and the meatballs tasted...
John T.
2/13/2025
Just ordered a pizza tonight It had soap on it the parts that didn't we're ok but once we bit into the soap we threw the rest out There were many parts That were contaminated its disgusting that...
See a problem?
