Annmarie M.
7/27/2025
I lived in Middle Village my whole life and 13 years ago moved to Long Island! I stopped at Carlos pizzeria on one of the hardest days of my life it was around 9:00 PM with my family. I was at...
Carlos Pizza
$
Closed
(194)
Photos
7402 Metropolitan Ave
Middle Village, NY 11379
The original Carlos Pizza has been open since 1966. We take pride in serving our communities and baseball league in the neighborhood with quality Italian food and authentic pizza that keeps your craving high. Make your next dining experience more tasteful with menu items from our pizza restaurant in Middle Village, New York.
Reviews
4.5194 reviews
Gordon Y.
11/5/2023
Though it's a good slice, not sure about all the raves and the extremely high rating. Personally, I have been here several times and would rate it a solid 7/10. Unfortunately, I prefer a zestier...
Bakchun K.
3/26/2024
I've tried a ton of NY pizza places so my expectations might be a bit high. I had the plain slices and they were decent, not overly thick crust with a thin layer of cheese. Prices are more...
Christina I.
2/17/2024
Ever since I went to Italy, I've been trying to find pizza and other food that tastes just like it's been in Italy. I have yet to find that until this place. Their rice ball is almost exactly like...
Robert Z.
5/9/2025
Been going there for for 36 years, foods great Sal Frankie and Anthony , are good people , it's old world pizzeria, don't pass it by ,
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.