Carlos Pizza

$
Closed
yelp logo

(197)

Call
Website

Photos

7402 Metropolitan Ave
Middle Village, NY 11379
+1 (718) 894-7915
http://www.theoriginalcarlospizzeria.net
The original Carlos Pizza has been open since 1966. We take pride in serving our communities and baseball league in the neighborhood with quality Italian food and authentic pizza that keeps your craving high. Make your next dining experience more tasteful with menu items from our pizza restaurant in Middle Village, New York.

Reviews

yelp logo
4.5197 reviews
Matt
9/13/2025

One of my favorite spots in all of New York Great pizza. Nice guys that work there. Quaint little neighborhood pizza shop

Read more on Yelp
Marisa D.
11/6/2025

Great service & very nice people. Food is awesome! I live in California. My daughter went to St. John's. We were able to go 2xs & enjoyed it both times! We found it driving by after going to...

Read more on Yelp
Samantha S.
10/8/2025

I'm kind of disappointed Carlos use to be soo good...I feel like depending on the day it's not always great....the slices are barely warmed up they give you cold tomato sauce...last time I ordered...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Gordon Y.
Gordon Y.
11/5/2023

Though it's a good slice, not sure about all the raves and the extremely high rating. Personally, I have been here several times and would rate it a solid 7/10. Unfortunately, I prefer a zestier...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Bakchun K.
Bakchun K.
3/26/2024

I've tried a ton of NY pizza places so my expectations might be a bit high. I had the plain slices and they were decent, not overly thick crust with a thin layer of cheese. Prices are more...

Read more on Yelp
Owner verified
See a problem?

You might also like

Domenick’s Pizza
Eating places

Domenick’s Pizza

25
•
$
"I came here for my lunch break during jury duty and ordered two slices of the Domenick's special. What a huge slice, topped with a variety of meats and veggies. Only ~$6 a slice, not much pricier..."
photo of Ming L.
Santoni's Ristorante & Pizzeria
Eating places, Italian restaurant

Santoni's Ristorante & Pizzeria

100
•
$
"We usually order a plain cheese pizza from Santoni's so we've never had any issues ordering in the past. We changed things up this time and ordered a large pizza half cheese and half..."
photo of Krystle T.
Marino's Trattoria
Eating places, Italian restaurant

Marino's Trattoria

55
•
$
"They should get 5 stars just for their chicken parm wrap w vodka sauce! If that sounds good to you then get it, you won't regret it. Service is always good and their plain pizza also is pretty good."
photo of Mike N.
United States›New York›Middle Village›Carlos Pizza

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.