Debbie M.
9/30/2024
this place has the most delicious food. Everything is fresh. Everything taste wonderful. The people are so nice. The owner is fantastic. She is a sweetheart. they catered my mom's 92nd birthday....
Carlito's Pizzeria
$
Open
(5)
25 Patchogue Yaphank Rd
Patchogue, NY 11772
Carlito's Pizzeria, located in East Patchogue, NY, offers a diverse menu that features classic pizzas, hearty pasta dishes, and a variety of appetizers. Known for their best-selling pizzas, including Grandma Pizza and Eggplant Pie, this pizzeria prides itself on using quality ingredients to satisfy a range of tastes.
In addition to their extensive pizza selection, Carlito's Pizzeria serves a variety of salads, heroes, and delicious desserts, making it an ideal stop for any meal. With options for catering, they are well-equipped to handle gatherings of any size, providing a taste of authentic Italian cuisine to the local community.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.05 reviews
Petey C.
4/26/2025
Only came in here because I dropped my uhual off next door. It's a notch higher than a NYC dollar slice. Absolutely subpar pizza.
Michele M.
5/22/2025
Absolute worst customer service I've ever experienced! I ordered 2 heroes and a plain pie, the pizza was good enough, but the heroes were disgusting! I'm Italian and can tell you for certain that...
Katie M.
2/3/2024
We've tried just about every pizza place in the Patchogue/Medford area and Carlito's is by far our favorite. Now we order from here almost every week. Perfect crust - not too doughy, not too thin....
Theresa S.
2/17/2023
Spent $35 for a pizza, garlic knots and greek salad. The pizza was undercooked, the garlic knots were very greasy, the salad..very light on the feta cheese. Not worth it. I am still hungry!!...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.