This is my neighborhood deli, and I'm embarassed to say I don't frequent it enough. My days of slurping down BECs on the reg are way behind me, and the cost to eat out is just too much right now....
Carleton Avenue Deli
(33)
Photos
Carleton Avenue Deli, located in East Islip, NY, has been a beloved staple in the community since 1988, known for serving only the best and freshest ingredients. With over 30 years of experience, the deli has earned the trust of its customers, offering a range of delicious meals and daily specials.
In addition to its regular menu, Carleton Avenue Deli specializes in catering services for a variety of events, including weddings, corporate galas, and family reunions. Their dedicated staff ensures that each catered event is marked by exceptional food and outstanding service, making every gathering truly memorable.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
Great burgers, nice hot trays for lunch over all clean deli. Easy to get to from anywhere in the Islip area.
I purchased a premade Greek salad with Chicken wrap. The wrap size was normal to small, no side potato salad or macaroni or drink was offered with the purchase for a total of $13.02. Yes $13.02...
great chicken noodle soup! good service also. many great breakfast and lunch options also. def give them a try if in the neighborhood
My favorite deli !! The menu is extensive and everything on it is delicious! I'm a fan of their egg sandwiches and the Ruben. The owners, Bob & John, along w the entire crew are friendly and...
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.








