Brian R.
5/10/2024
Awesome pizza Very consistent. Their Wed night Large Cheese pizza to go is a A great deal less than $9.00 Brian been the chief baker for several decades!
Captain Tony's Pizza
$
Closed
(35)
Photos
385 Winton Rd N
Rochester, NY 14610
In 1972, Antonio Martella opened the first Captain Tony's Pizza & Pasta Emporium in the fine state of New York. The entire family pitched in and helped, including his young son Michael. Grown up and away at college, Michael found that old adage to be true that you just can't beat home cooking, dad's pizza that is. In all of his travels at that time, sampling a variety of pizzas in several states across the country, he was not able to find a pizza that rivaled his own father's. His cousin (also named Michael) also agreed and the family decided to share this great pizza with the world by expanding into a franchise in 1985.
Find related places
Reviews
3.035 reviews
Jen R.
3/18/2024
This is a tiny walk in walk out spot on North Winton. We ordered a pizza and 10 wings. It took about 25 minutes. We got the "Classic" which had cheese, onions, green peppers, mushrooms and...
MrBkellison K.
11/26/2024
The food was very poor, I ordered a meatball sub, the roll was chewey like it was in the microwave and the meatballs were bland and no taste whatsoever. Don't waste your money at this place
John W.
7/30/2024
It's been 45 years since I've had Captain Tony's Pizza, and revisiting it tonight was like stepping back in time. The place hadn't changed, and the pizza was just as good as I remembered.
J K.
9/10/2022
I've always had great pizza from CT's!! Lots of cheese n pepperoni. They never skimp and their mozzarella tastes better than a lot of other pizza places. They also don't disappoint with Buffalo...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.